Home Categories Send inquiry

Comparison of Alkaline and Carbon Zinc Batteries

Alkaline battery
Alkaline batteries and carbon-zinc batteries are two common types of dry cell batteries, with significant differences in performance, usage scenarios, and environmental characteristics. Here are the main comparisons between them:

1. Electrolyte:
- Carbon-zinc battery: Uses acidic ammonium chloride as the electrolyte.
- Alkaline battery: Uses alkaline potassium hydroxide as the electrolyte.

2. Energy density & capacity:
- Carbon-zinc battery: Lower capacity and energy density.
- Alkaline battery: Higher capacity and energy density, typically 4-5 times that of carbon-zinc batteries.

3. Discharge characteristics:
- Carbon-zinc battery: Unsuitable for high-rate discharge applications.
- Alkaline battery: Suitable for high-rate discharge applications, such as electronic dictionaries and CD players.

4. Shelf life & storage:
- Carbon-zinc battery: Shorter shelf life (1-2 years), prone to rotting, liquid leakage, corrosive, and power loss of about 15% per year.
- Alkaline battery: Longer shelf life (up to 8 years), steel tube casing, no chemical reactions causing leakage.

5. Application areas:
- Carbon-zinc battery: Primarily used for low-power devices, such as quartz clocks and wireless mice.
- Alkaline battery: Suitable for high-current appliances, including pagers and PDAs.

6. Environmental factors:
- Carbon-zinc battery: Contains heavy metals such as mercury, cadmium, and lead, posing a greater risk to the environment.
- Alkaline battery: Utilizes different electrolytic materials and internal structures, free of harmful heavy metals like mercury, cadmium, and lead, making it more environmentally friendly.

7. Temperature resistance:
- Carbon-zinc battery: Poor temperature resistance, with rapid power loss below 0 degrees Celsius.
- Alkaline battery: Better temperature resistance, functioning normally within a range of -20 to 50 degrees Celsius.

Primary battery

In summary, alkaline batteries outperform carbon-zinc batteries in many aspects, particularly in energy density, lifespan, applicability, and environmental friendliness. However, due to their lower cost, carbon-zinc batteries still have a market for some low-power small devices. With technological advancements and increased environmental awareness, an increasing number of consumers prefer alkaline batteries or advanced rechargeable batteries.